Whisker’s AI-powered litter robot thinks my cats swapped bodies

Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

Whisker’s AI-powered litter robot thinks my cats swapped bodies

The $899 Litter-Robot 5 Pro is a great pooper-scooper wrapped in AI that just doesn’t work.

Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy

If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

All the smart home news, reviews, and gadgets you need to know about

is a senior reviewer with over twenty years of experience. She covers smart home, IoT, and connected tech, and has written previously for Wirecutter, Wired, Dwell, BBC, and US News.

The greatest invention in pet tech in recent years is the litter robot. A machine that scoops your kitties’ poop so you don’t have to — what else could a cat owner possibly want? How about insights into your kitty’s litter box usage that could flag health issues? Sign me up. But I have two feline friends… No worries, kitty facial recognition can handle that.

At least, that is the idea behind the Litter-Robot 5 Pro, the highest-end model from the OG robotic pooper scooper company Whisker. Boasting a dual camera system and an array of sensors to literally sniff out your cat’s deposits, all wrapped up with AI algorithms and machine learning, the 5 Pro promises to not only deal with my boys’ bathroom habits but also accurately monitor and track them. It failed.

Who could get these two precious faces mixed up? Smokey, left, and Boone, right, are indoor/outdoor kitties who love their Litter Robot, even if it can’t tell them apart.

I spent six months testing the $899 Litter-Robot 5 Pro, alongside its budget counterpart, the $599 Litter-Robot Evo, both of which launched late last year. These ingenious devices work using sensors and motors. The cat goes into the large globe lined with litter; the sensors register him while he does his thing, and once he’s left, the robot rotates the drum to filter and sift the waste into the sealed bin below.

How to take better photos of your pets

How my smart home helps care for my pets

This takes away a yucky daily chore; you only have to empty the drawer about once a week, and it hides the gross litter box itself from view, while containing most of the smell. A fully featured app gives you remote control of most of the device’s functions; you can also check the waste and litter levels and see your kitty’s weight thanks to an onboard scale. A litter robot is a great gadget if you travel a lot, as it leaves your kitty with a cleaner place to go during his abandonment.

The Litter Robot Pro 5 is very large and almost 30 inches tall. It takes up a good deal of room in my small laundry room. Its globe is roomier than the Evo and LR4 making it suitable for more and larger cats — up to 5 topping out at 30lbs!

Whisker currently has four models: the Litter-Robot Evo, the Litter-Robot 4, the Litter-Robot 5, and the 5 Pro. They all work this same way to “scoop.” Today, I wouldn’t recommend paying the premium for the 5 Pro’s AI features — because they just don’t work. I was also disappointed in the tradeoffs that come with the Evo compared to the Litter-Robot 4.

I wouldn’t recommend paying the premium for the 5 Pro’s AI features — because they just don’t work.

There’s no litter-level monitoring on the Evo, so the app doesn’t alert you when it’s low; it supports fewer and smaller cats, has a smaller bin, and no night light. It also doesn’t work with the litter hopper accessory Whisker sells.

While the Evo’s footprint is better for tight spaces, its build quality didn’t feel as sturdy, and its waste drawer is finicky and doesn’t always shut properly. I do like that it has an LCD screen to tell you what it’s doing, as does the 5 Pro. These are both better solutions than the confusing LED indicator lights on the LR4.

The Evo has a similar footprint to the 5, but it’s shorter and slightly narrower. It fit neatly into the corner of a small bedroom in my house. Though the litter mat had to go. The Evo is suitable for 1 to 2 cats who are under 19 pounds. This is Osa, a female kitten who joined our family a week ago. She’s too little to use the robot without supervision.

As a pooper-scooper, the Litter-Robot 5 Pro dispatches waste superbly. Its bigger bin, more intuitive controls — including that LCD screen — and larger dome make it a better robot overall than its predecessor, the $699 Litter-Robot 4. But the smarts are seriously lacking.

I have a middle-aged fur baby, and the appeal of this significantly more expensive device was the promise it could keep him healthier for longer by catching possible issues earlier. Thankfully, Smokey is currently fit as a fiddle, but in my time using the 5 Pro, its $8-a-month Whisker Plus subscription that covers its AI health features and video storage didn’t deliver one actionable or useful insight.

Its new WasteID system, which purportedly can tell the difference between #1 and #2 and dispatch the latter faster to reduce odors, repeatedly failed to accurately identify waste, and its two new cameras couldn’t tell my large gray and white tabby from my small, sleek tuxedo kitty, getting confused between them and eventually merging them into two identical cats.

I was also disappointed that I couldn’t use the camera to watch my kitty poop. Yes, I’m weird, but I’m also not alone — the Litter-Robot 4 has a camera mount accessory for exactly this reason! Getting an inside look at what’s happening in the litter tray before the results are whisked away is valuable data for many cat parents.

While the front-facing camera records visits, the interior cameras only allow a live view; catching a cat in the act is very hard (I only managed it once). The advertising for the product implies you’ll get recordings from both, but even with the monthly subscription, only the front-facing camera, which catches the kitty coming in, records anything. Whisker tells me the poop-view is coming soon.

1/3The 5 Pro has two cameras and several sensors to keep track of your kitty.

The camera wasn’t totally useless; I did appreciate being able to remotely check in and make sure there wasn’t a kitty trapped in the litter box if I received a “cycle interrupted” or an obstruction detected alert, features that stop the globe rotating if there’s any activity detected while the machine is rotating.

The robot still thinks my cat is lighter than he is; I wish my bathroom scale did that

Just be very careful where you place the litter robot. It took me about a week to realize that where I had put mine, the front-facing camera not only caught my kitties’ bathroom trips, but also those of anyone who used the powder room across the hall. There is an option to turn on recording only when a cat is spotted, but — as many cat parents will know — feline friends like to accompany their owners into the bathroom!

For me, the 5 Pro’s biggest letdown was the kitty facial recognition feature, called Cat ID. The front-facing camera is supposed to recognize which cat is entering and then assign any business to that cat in the app’s history section. It can apparently keep track of up to five cats, but it struggled mightily with my two who don’t look a lick alike.

After a week or so of use, the app presents a PawPrint setup option, Whisker’s name for facial recognition, where it shows you images the camera has captured of your cats, and you pick the two best — mine were all fairly bad. Whisker does sell a $29 RFID PetTag to help with cats that look similar; my cats don’t wear collars, but a $900 machine advertising facial recognition shouldn’t need a wearable to tell two different-looking cats apart.

1/3These were the images PawPrint presented to me to set up CatID. There was no option to change them or upload my own.

According to Whisker, things like poor lighting and bad initial imaging can throw the camera off, and when it’s no